1703. What factors do we consider when we evaluate evidence you submit?
When we evaluate a particular document you submit as evidence, we consider factors such as:
-
The source of information from which the record was made. Was the person originally furnishing the information in a position to know the facts?
-
The purpose for which the record was made. Was there any reason to falsify or distort the facts?
-
The formality of the document. Was it made under oath? Is it a public record? Were there witnesses to its execution? Was a penalty provided for a false statement?
-
The age of the document. Was the record made at, or shortly after, the time the event occurred?
-
The custody of the document. Has it been in possession of someone who might have reason to change it?
-
Its appearance. Lack of erasures, etc. Does it appear altered from its original form?
-
The consistency of all the evidence relating to a particular matter; and
-
Whether the person furnishing the information has an interest in the claim for which the proof is needed.
Last Revised: March, 2001